The Primary Difference Between Homeowners Insurance and Renters Insurance

Both homeowners insurance and renters insurance offer financial protection to homeowners against damage to the property, legal liability expenses, medical expenses for other people, and costs incurred while staying away from home. The main difference is the nature of the property damage covered.

The individual who owns a home or apartment has homeowners insurance, which covers personal items and the structure of the home. A tenant typically purchases renters insurance. This type of insurance covers personal items in terms of theft or damage, but not the building itself.

What Differentiates Renter's Insurance from Home Owner's Insurance?

For one, the only difference between homeowners insurance and renters insurance is that home insurance policies offer dwelling coverage. Also, policies are virtually the same which means that both renters and homeowners insurance policies are not needed for the same house.

Homeowner insurance is comprised of five principal components, which include dwelling, personal property, personal liability, additional living expenses, and medical payments. Renters insurance has all of those features apart from the first, making it a more affordable version of homeowners insurance for tenants.

What are the coverage aspects of renters and homeowners insurance?

Both homeowners and renters insurance avert financial loss due to damages incurred by sudden or unforeseen circumstances. The events covered, often referred to as perils, usually vary with each insurance company; however, they are fundamentally the same. Damage resulting from a covered peril allows a claim to be filed with the insurance. Once your claim is approved, repairs or replacements are made to the damaged items (minus your preselected deductible).

Dwelling coverage: A feature exclusive to homeowners insurance.

“Dwelling” encompasses the physical location of a house. Dwelling coverage is concerned with the damage inflicted on the house (walls, roof, floors, doors, and other parts of the structure). If you live in a condo or house, you are going to need home or condo insurance to cover the expenses incurred during such occurrences. Renters’ insurance policies do not include dwelling coverage. This is because tenants are not responsible for damage to the building that is beyond their control.

Most homeowners insurance policies provide coverage against a set of standard common perils for the dwelling. Damage caused by wind and hail are among the most common, while fire and lightning are two of the costliest.

Risks covered under homeowners insurance coverage are Fire, Smoke, Civil unrest or riots, Hail, Lightning, Explosions, Vehicles, and Theft. Additionally, Vandalism or malicious mischief, Windstorm, Weight of ice, snow and sleet, Water Damage caused by freezes or sudden plumbing malfunctioning, Trees and other falling objects are also included in the coverage. Windstorms and hail are also included with the understanding that they will not surpass the agreed value. The claim will also be sustained if the tank is set on fire. Van ladden or Scholy burning the house and all its contents will be set ablaze also captures the clause.

An HO-1 policy has the least coverage, while an HO-3 policy has the most comprehensive coverage (All of these perils alongside vandalism, Malicious mischief, and Sprinkler damage). However, Both policies have a caveat in the form of non-coverage for flooding and earthquakes. If you have what’s called an open-peril policy, these exclusions need to be named. If you have a named-peril policy, all perils not explicitly stated as covered will be excluded from dwelling coverage.

Exclusions usually not covered in the homeowner insurance dwelling policies are:

Government confiscation, demolition, or rebuilding in compliance with the existing building laws
Flood
Earth movements such as earthquakes, sinkholes, or land sliding activities
Loss of power not related to a power source cut near the residence
Negligence of the homeowner
War and radiation perils

Both homeowner and renter insurance cover personal belongings, personal liability, temporary accommodation costs, and medical expenses insurance.

There are four types of coverage offered by both homeowner and renter’s insurance. The process of coverage is the same.

Coverage of personal property:

Most homeowners and renters insurance policies cover the loss, destruction, or damage of personal property insured, which includes clothing, furniture, television, etc.… When purchasing homeowners insurance, your personal property coverage on an insurance dwelling policy will typically be set at 50% of dwelling coverage, which can be adjusted but not increased after purchase.

When purchasing renters insurance, personal property coverage is the most important base one has to choose. It is the most critical component as well as the most costly aspect of the policy.

Similar to dwelling coverage, personal property protection is subject to restrictions against certain risks. Most of the common restrictions found in dwelling coverage, including flood and earthquake, are applicable here as well. Both homeowners and renters should also note that certain expensive items are likely to be covered differently than other ordinary items and may also have a limit on the amount payable under such coverage.

For example, your jewellery may have a coverage sublimit of $2,000. This implies that even if the total limit on the coverage for personal property was $20,000, your insurance company would only pay you $2,000 (less your deductible) if the jewellery is stolen. If you possess many valuable items, you will find it beneficial to purchase an endorsement to assist you in increasing these limits.

Personal liability protection:

Homeowners and renters’ policies both include liability protection, which provides coverage against injury to another person or damage to someone else’s property. For instance, if someone decides to sue you for unintentionally pouring hot coffee on their lap. They will be able to pay for any legal action required to protect themselves and any fines that may need to be paid, including in any future court cases. Standard homeowners and renters insurance policies include personal liability protection of $100,000, but unlike most other policies, these can be adjusted without great expense.

Additional living expenses (ALE) coverage:

Known as coverage for loss of use, ALE coverage alleviates the financial burden of relocating from your residence to some other place. ALE provides reimbursement for additional expenses away from the usual place of residence that you must incur in case of a specific loss. For example, ALE helps pay for hotel expenses when your apartment is being restored due to smoke damage. Your offer will be matched to a predefined dollar limit or a fixed term, for example, three months.

Medical payments coverage:

Medical payments coverage knows no legal fault; personal liability coverage is without reason for fault conditions. Medical payment coverage is important because it pays for injuries from accidents in your house without having to prove it was the homeowner’s fault. Medical coverage under homeowners insurance can be an exclusion from the occupants’ insurance. This is common when the coverage cost exceeds value, owing to age. Value is typically limited to approximately $2000.

What is the cost of homeowners insurance vs. renters insurance?

Homeowners insurance is more expensive than renters insurance. This is so because home policies include all the provisions covered under renters insurance along with the repair costs for the building. Nationally, the average figure for homeowners insurance rests at $2,377, whereas renters insurance has an average figure of $173.

Why does homeowners insurance cost more than renters insurance?

It’s quite simple, the price of an insurance premium is higher for homeowners than renters partly due to the fact that it ensures more valuable and highly vulnerable properties. For example, breaks to the dwelling area of a house will only be covered by a home insurance policy. Again, the dwelling itself is much more susceptible to sustaining damages than the personal belongings inside the house and a lot more expensive to rebuild than personal property.

According to the National Association of Home Builders, the average cost to build a single family home starts at $392,000 all the way to $500,000. On the contrary, State Farm suggests that the renter’s properties combined amount to $30,000. Hence, a covered event like a total loss of an average person’s personal belongings pales in comparison to what a home sustains in damages.

While determining the premiums, every insurance company ultimately comes to a calculation that involves how much they will have to pay in claims to their clientele. Because companies anticipate spending significantly more on home insurance claims than Tenants, as a norm, home insurance is more restrictive than renters insurance policies.

Renters insurance vs. landlord insurance: Are they the same?

Landlord insurance or rental property insurance is different from renters insurance and home insurance. Landlords cannot risk using a homeowner’s policy because it will not protect against damages incurred due to renters. An insurance policy for landlords will cover dwelling, limited property damage, and legal liability for a property owner.

As owners, landlords are accountable for any unanticipated damages to the premises of the building. For instance, if the unit endures any infringement from the renters, the landlord will incur all the costs. For these reasons, utilizing a landlord insurance policy will advantage those renting properties on a continuous basis.

Loss to rental house property is covered under landlord policy, but only to the extent of damages to personal items, such as lawnmowers or snowblowers. In those circumstances, tenants will need to purchase renters insurance policies.

Learn more